Resurrection for 2018?

So 2 years ago, I set up this site to collect recommendations for Hugo nominees. It generated some good interest and many insightful recommendations. (Thank you all again for that!) Unfortunately, last year at this time I was buried in comprehensive exams for my PhD and wasn’t able to run another recommendation collection.

However, is there interest in something like this for the 2018 Hugos?

I would be willing to collect and post recommendations centered around themed weeks (so that even the less popular categories get some love and attention), and have a better idea how to run things smoother than I did the first time.

It would rely on all of you to write recommendations. Unless you are willing to submit for at least some categories, then it would be rather quiet and pointless. So, is there anyone out there?

Advertisements

Uprooted, Best Novel 2016, Part 5 of 5

Here is the fifth of the five Best Novel 2016 Finalists. We will be presenting them in alphabetical order during this week.

Uprooted by Naomi Novik

What are your thoughts on this novel? Likes and dislikes? Does it deserve the Hugo?

Slan, Best Novel 1941, Part 5 of 5

Here is the fifth of the five Best Novel 1941 Finalists. We will be presenting them in alphabetical order during this week.

Slan by A.E. Van Vogt

What are your thoughts on this novel? Likes and dislikes? Does it deserve the Hugo?

Seveneves, Best Novel 2016, Part 4 of 5

Here is the fourth of the five Best Novel 2016 Finalists. We will be presenting them in alphabetical order during this week.

Seveneves: A Novel by Neal Stephenson

What are your thoughts on this novel? Likes and dislikes? Does it deserve the Hugo?

The Reign of Wizardry, Best Novel 1941, Part 4 of 5

Here is the fourth of the five Best Novel 1941 Finalists. We will be presenting them in alphabetical order during this week.

The Reign of Wizardry by Jack Williamson

What are your thoughts on this novel? Likes and dislikes? Does it deserve the Hugo?

Fifth Season, Best Novel 2016, Part 3 of 5

Here is the third of the five Best Novel 2016 Finalists. We will be presenting them in alphabetical order during this week.

The Fifth Season by N.K. Jemisin

What are your thoughts on this novel? Likes and dislikes? Does it deserve the Hugo?

Kallocain, Best Novel 1941, Part 3 of 5

Here is the third of the five Best Novel 1941 Finalists. We will be presenting them in alphabetical order during this week.

Kallocain by Karin Boye

What are your thoughts on this novel? Likes and dislikes? Does it deserve the Hugo?